Henning Computer Services - Pre-Built vs. Custom Built PCs... Is there a difference?

The main reason for buying a pre-built computer is price. Today especially you can purchase a base model pre-built computer at most retail stores for around $400, complete with everything the average user would need. Quite often they include a monitor, speakers and in some instances, a printer. Also, as a way of enticing consumers to buy, most pre-built computer manufacturers also known as Original Equipment Manufacturers (OEM) such as; Dell, HP, Compaq, Gateway, e-Machine, etc will often bundle software so that you can begin using your computer right out of the box. Finally, you can usually contact a vendor for warranty repairs, if the computer misbehaves during the warranty period. Unfortunately that’s where the advantages end.


There are a couple major disadvantages of buying a pre-built computer. The first is that more and more computer manufacturers are using proprietary parts. In many cases this shouldn’t be an issue, however, I’m sure we have all heard of something that has had a major problem after the warranty expires and computers are no exception. It’s when you attempt to replace or upgrade a part that you will find yourself at the mercy of the OEM. I have known OEM's that have charged customers as much as 5 times the cost for a replacement part. In other words a part that may cost $20.00 for a custom built computer could easily cost over $100.00 from an OEM. You may also find that a failed proprietary part is no longer available. I have found this to be true with failed power-supplies and a 3rd party replacement may not always be available. Furthermore, support is generally provided for OEM’s via an off-shore helpdesk, usually in India. Also, some 3rd party support vendors will decline repairs depending on the proprietary part that is involved. As a result you may find it difficult to find a local repair shop and you may have to ship the computer back to the OEM for repairs (expect longer turn around times in most cases).


I recently took in an out-of-warranty desktop and laptop, both needed new motherboards due to overheating. The cost of repair would have been more than the replacement cost of these systems.


The second disadvantage is that you cannot be sure about the integrity of the parts used. Some OEM's have been known to integrate substandard parts into their computers because of the substantial discounts they receive for these parts. If the computer passes the OEM's benchmark and quality test, the machine will be shipped to the end user with a refurbished part installed. In my 29+ years of  experience with computers I have seen OEM's that provide users with a very nice and well built computer case, but will include a cheap motherboard along with a proprietary power supply. One well known OEM often develops systems that require proprietary memory and in some cases proprietary hard drives. These cheap parts will increase the chances of system failure. My advice; if you plan to buy a pre-built computer, make sure the OEM has a solid reputation and avoid the low cost configurations that are so often pushed on customers at most retail locations.


The main advantage of buying a custom built computer is that the system can be built exactly to your needs or specifications, unlike OEM’s where you have to adapt to what they give you.  In custom built computers you can specify everything from the brand name of the motherboard to the type and size of the case. Every part in it is standard so that repairing and upgrading it is faster, easier and less expensive.


Custom built PCs give you the option of having a system built that fits your budget and if you elect an inexpensive motherboard it's your decision. Support generally can be obtained from most local 3rd party sources, or directly from the parts manufacturer. The upgrade path will generally be easier and less expensive.


The disadvantages of buying a custom built computer is that generally there is no additional software bundled with the computer beyond the Operating System. Buying additional software can significantly increase the price to the computer system.


If your work is mission critical you may actually save money by buying a custom built computer rather than buying a high-end OEM system. If you are using graphic intensive applications, or online gaming software, you may be better served by buying a custom built computer.


Whether you buy or build your computer, support should ultimately be available from a number of sources. However, support for proprietary systems may be hard to find for out of warranty pre-built/OEM systems.  The standard warranty for new pre-built /OEM computer ranges from 90 days to 3 years whereas warranties apply to the individual parts for custom-build computers.